The Founding of Warwick: A Messy Beginning

Every town has an origin story, but the founding of Warwick, Rhode Island, was messier than most, complete with a disputed land deal, an armed raid, a heresy trial, and a voyage to England to set things right. It’s also the backdrop for a family mystery. My sixth-great-grandmother, Sara Tefft, was buried on the very first piece of land an Englishman bought there. The date on her gravestone has been read as both March 16, 1642, and March 16, 1672. The story of how Warwick began strongly suggests which one is right.

John Greene Sr.: The First Settler

John Greene, Sr. purchased his land at Occupessatuxet Cove—the land on which Sara Tefft was buried—in October 1642. Occupessatuxet Cove lies on the western shore of Narragansett Bay, on the northern edge of what is now Warwick. Greene’s was the first land purchased by an English settler in that part of Narragansett Country. It was the first step toward the founding of Warwick, part of a plan by the Gortonites—a group of men led by the outspoken Samuel Gorton—to escape the control of the original settlers of Pawtuxet, a settlement several miles to the north, on the far southern outskirts of Providence. The Gortonites intended to relocate to a sixty-thousand-acre tract of Narragansett land adjacent to Greene’s land, known as the Shawomet Purchase.

Samuel Gorton: Troublemaker or Dissenter?

Gorton arrived in Massachusetts in 1637 and immediately became known as a troublemaker. He called himself an “Ultra-Puritan” and was, by all accounts, a devout but contentious individual (D’Amato n.d.-b). Driven out of Boston and Plymouth, Gorton made his way to Portsmouth, where he got into disputes with his neighbors and the courts and was once again driven out. From there, he went to Providence, where the powerful William Arnold became his arch-nemesis.

Arnold wrote that Gorton “showed himself an insolent, railing and turbulent person” (D’Amato n.d.-b). Even Roger Williams, normally a tolerant man and a peacemaker, wrote in 1640 that “Master Gorton having abused high and low at Aqidnick, is now bewitching and bemadding poor Providence, with his uncleane and foul censures of all the ministers of this country … and also denying all visible and externall ordinances …” (Rhode Island Digital History Project n.d.). William Arnold, Roger Williams, and a few other men were responsible for Gorton’s failure to become a freeman in Providence.

Historians have argued about Gorton for nearly four centuries: his admirers see a persecuted dissenter, while his critics see a chronic troublemaker. Most modern scholars see a bit of both. (For differing views of Samuel Gorton’s life and importance, see the sources below.)

The Feud at Pawtuxet

William Arnold, too, had his followers and his enemies. In 1638, Arnold and several other men moved to Pawtuxet, an outlying part of Providence on its southern boundary. They did so to secure more land and to move away from Providence, where they feared that undesirable settlers might gain control of the government. Soon, Samuel Gorton became the most feared of these “undesirables”—perhaps because he was intelligent, persuasive, and gathering a following of influential men in Providence, Portsmouth, and Newport, not the least of whom was John Greene Sr.

After failing to become a freeman in Providence, Gorton and some of his followers moved to the Pawtuxet area around 1641, settling across the river from Arnold and his followers. The Arnold faction was so alarmed by the arrival of the Gortonites in Pawtuxet that in September 1642, they placed themselves and their land under the jurisdiction of Massachusetts, giving the Bay Colony a much-coveted foothold in the Narragansett Bay area (Rhode Island Digital History Project n.d.). It also gave the Bay Colony an excuse to pursue the Gortonites, many of whom had at some point been banished from Massachusetts or Plymouth. The move backfired locally: many of the earlier Pawtuxet settlers moved away or sided with Gorton (Rhode Island Digital History Project n.d.).

During the fall of 1642, relations between the Gortonites and the Pawtuxet men and their allies in Massachusetts became so fraught that the Gortonites feared for their lives. Gorton said of this period: “For we saw that they did not only endeavor to take away our livelihood, but intended to take away our lives also …” (Ely 1887, 27).

The Shawomet Purchase and the Founding of Warwick

The Shawomet deed is dated January 12, 1642, because until 1752, England and its colonies still followed the Julian calendar, and began the legal new year on March 25. Therefore, a January date written as 1642 would fall in what we would call 1643, according to the New Style or Gregorian calendar.

Read at face value, the 1642 date would put the deed before Greene’s October purchase and before the Gortonites arrived at Shawomet, which is out of sync with the historical record. Based on Gorton’s correspondence and other documents, many modern historians agree that the Shawomet Purchasers took possession of Shawomet on or shortly after November 20, 1642, and signed the deed roughly two months later, on January 12, 1643 (D’Amato n.d.-a). The sequence of events leaves no doubt: the deed belongs to 1643 (New Style), not 1642.

Sometime during the winter of 1642 into 1643, the Shawomet Purchasers—eleven or twelve, depending on the source—located their first settlement just south of Greene’s personal land, near Conimicut Point. In the spring of 1643—we don’t know the exact date—the Shawomet settlers sent for their wives and children and began to build a community they called Mill Creek (D’Amato n.d.-a).

The Siege

Once they’d settled in Mill Creek, the Gortonites may have briefly felt safe from the harassment of the Pawtuxet men and their Massachusetts allies, but they soon found themselves in even deeper trouble. In September 1643, the Massachusetts General Court summoned the Gortonites to appear. The reply, probably written by Gorton but signed by another Shawomet Purchaser, Randall Holden, was addressed “To the great, honored and Idol General, now set up in the Massachusetts, whose pretended equity in the distribution of justice unto the souls and bodies of men, is nothing else but a mere device of man, according to the ancient custom and sleights of Satan …” (Fuller 1875, 17). The letter continued in the same tone.

In response to this infuriating letter, Massachusetts replied that its commissioners, along with an armed guard, would be sent to subjugate the Shawomet men. In turn, the Shawomet men sent a message to the commissioners warning them not to invade Mill Creek, to which the commissioners sent a chilling reply stating that they “wished to speak with [the Shawomet men] and show them their misdeeds, and lead them to repent, failing in which they should ‘look upon them as men prepared for slaughter’ and they should act accordingly” (Fuller 1875, 18).

Facing imminent attack, the Shawomet men helped most of the women and children of Mill Creek escape by boat to neighboring plantations (settlements), while a few stayed behind and hid in nearby woods during the attack. Then the men fortified a house and prepared to defend it. After a failed attempt by four Providence men to mediate between the two parties, the Massachusetts commissioners began the siege on October 3, attempting at one point to burn the house where the Shawomet men were sheltering. After several days under siege, the Shawomet men surrendered.

The Aftermath

Although most of the women and children were safe, John Greene’s wife and one other woman who had hidden in the woods died of exposure. Of the eleven men defending Mill Creek, all but John Greene, who either escaped or was quickly released, were taken as prisoners to Boston to face trial for “heresy and sedition” (Fuller 1875, 20).

Following their trial and conviction, Gorton and six of his followers were put in irons and sent to various towns to work. Three others were given lesser sentences and held only briefly. After a brutal winter of hard labor, Gorton and his followers were released in the spring of 1644 and banished from Massachusetts and Shawomet. Along with their families, the men found sanctuary on Aquidneck Island in the towns of Newport and Portsmouth. Through all of this, Greene appears to have escaped punishment.

The Founding of Warwick: Rising from the Ruins of Shawomet

Later in 1644, Gorton, Greene, and Holden set sail for England from New Amsterdam (New York), having been banished from Massachusetts and barred from sailing out of Boston. They intended to have their lands restored and stop the harassment by Massachusetts. In 1646, the Commissioners for Plantations, who oversaw the colonies, ordered Massachusetts to let Shawomet’s residents “freely and quietly live and plant” without interference (Rhode Island Digital History Project n.d.). Gorton also received the protection of the Earl of Warwick. In 1648, he changed the name of Shawomet to Warwick to honor his benefactor.

This chronology of Warwick’s founding, and the resulting New Style date of the deed, is documented in an 1887 report to the Rhode Island Historical Society by a committee chaired by William D. Ely. It is also supported by later research by Don D’Amato, a former Warwick town historian. While Oliver Payson Fuller’s exhaustive History of Warwick, Rhode Island follows the same chronology, it oddly keeps the deed’s Old Style date of 1642 without noting that it doesn’t fit the sequence of events leading to the founding of Warwick.

Why the Founding of Warwick Rules Out 1642

The settlement of Shawomet, the future Warwick, has a direct bearing on the debate about the year on the Sara Tefft gravestone. Most nineteenth-century and some twentieth-century historians and antiquarians read March 16, 1642, as a modern date. If they were right, John Greene would not buy his land for another six and a half months. On March 16, 1642, the land would still have belonged to the Narragansetts, placing Sara Tefft in Narragansett Country with no other English settlers. It would have been the Narragansetts who buried her in the English fashion, under a headstone inscribed with an English epitaph.

Furthermore, we know the identities of the Shawomet settlers. None were named Tefft or anything remotely similar. The only Tefft known to have been in Rhode Island in the 1640s was John Tefft, who is recorded as having settled in Portsmouth in March 1643/4. John Tefft’s household was not recorded at that time, but later records show he was married to a woman named Mary and had two daughters (Mary and Tabitha) and two sons (Samuel and Joshua), all of whom were born in the 1640s or early 1650s. Joshua later married Sara, as shown by the birth record for their son Peter. No mention of an earlier Sara Tefft has been found except on the replacement gravestone.  

A Sara Tefft, who died in 1672, fits every record of the family that we have. A Sara Tefft who died in 1642 fits none of them—and she doesn’t fit anywhere in the story of the founding of Warwick, either.

Bibliography

Anthony, A. Craig. 1998. The Tefft Family & the Narragansett Controversy: A Window to the Creation of Rhode Island & Providence Plantations. Self-published. Held at the South County History Center. Finding aid updated June 27, 2022: www.southcountyhistorycenter.org. https://static1.squarespace.com/static/56f4318d906340eeb78ccce9/t/62b9e3d92968c45a5cec773f/1656349657615/TefftGenealogy_FindingAid_06272022.pdf. Not available online.

D’Amato, Don. n.d.-a. “The Attack on Shawomet.” Rhode Island Digital History Project. Accessed December 21, 2021. https://www.warwickhistory.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=92:conimicut-village-and-its-environs-the-attack-on-shawomet&catid=42&Itemid=95.

D’Amato, Don. n.d.-b. “Then and Now—A Long History.” Rhode Island Digital History Project. Accessed December 21, 2021. https://www.warwickhistory.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=90:conimicut-village-and-its-environs-then-a-now-a-long-history&catid=42&Itemid=95.

Ely, William D., and John A. Howland. 1887. “Report on the Settlement of Warwick, 1642: and the Seal of the R. I. Historical Society.” Proceedings of the Rhode Island Historical Society. Providence: J.A. & R.A. Reid. Accessed January 22, 2022. https://catalog.hathitrust.org/Record/009590927.

Fuller, Oliver Payson. 1875. The History of Warwick, Rhode Island, Settlement in 1642 to the Present Time. Providence: Angell, Burlingame. https://archive.org/details/historyofwarwick00fullrich.

Rhode Island Digital History Project. n.d. “Samuel Gorton (1593–1677).” Accessed September 13, 2026. https://www.warwickhistory.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=476:samuel-gorton-15931677&catid=57&Itemid=130.

Rhode Island Heritage Hall of Fame. n.d. “Samuel Gorton.” Accessed September 27, 2026. https://riheritagehalloffame.com/samuel-gorton/.

Wikipedia. 2026a. “John Greene (settler).” Last modified June 15, 2026. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Greene_(settler).

Wikipedia. 2026b. “Samuel Gorton.” Last modified September 27, 2026. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Samuel_Gorton.

When citing this work, please include the following information:
Janis, Margaret Tifft, "The Founding of Warwick: A Messy Beginning." Tengens: The History of the Tifft, Goodrich, Hallberg, and Watson Families, October 25, 2026. https://tengens.net/founding-of-warwick/

Following a fast-paced career, in her early sixties Margaret began to pursue her life-long fascination with her family history. When she isn't researching her ancestry or writing about her forebears, she travels with her husband Jim Janis, enjoys the wilderness of northern Minnesota, reads voraciously, and watches everything from historical documentaries to silly rom-coms on Netflix.

See my family tree on Ancestry.com here.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *